
Newsroom·New York Legislature·News
State Police Gave Light Penalties for Domestic Violence by Their Own
A New York Focus investigation of 18 State Police employees with substantiated domestic violence allegations found most got censure or short suspensions, and only three faced arrest. The agency says it has zero tolerance.
This article discusses domestic violence. It contains no graphic detail. Support: National Domestic Violence Hotline 800-799-7233; New York’s hotline 800-942-6906.
New York State Police employees whose domestic violence allegations the agency itself substantiated often received censure or short suspensions, and only three of 18 faced arrest, according to an investigation by the nonprofit newsroom New York Focus. One was fired. The agency says it has “zero tolerance for domestic violence or misconduct by its members.”
New York Focus published a guide to its findings on Monday, following its original investigation in October. Bloom isn’t naming the individual employees described in the files. The story here is the system: what the State Police records show, what the law requires, and what survivors can do when the person hurting them carries a badge.
01
What the State Police records show
The records cover 18 State Police employees with domestic abuse allegations that the department investigated and substantiated, New York Focus reported. Most of the incidents happened between 2014 and 2024, with examples dating back to 1998.
Here’s how the cases ended, according to New York Focus’s summary of its findings:
- Seven received censure and five or fewer days of suspension or lost vacation, sometimes with work probation.
- Five received 10 to 30 days of suspension or lost vacation.
- Three received censure alone or no consequences.
- One was fired, after an arrest out of state led to the discovery of other misconduct.
The reporters found evidence of only three of the 18 employees “facing arrest,” New York Focus reported. These were allegations the State Police themselves had found to be true.
02
What the law requires
New York law doesn’t leave arrests in family violence cases entirely to an officer’s discretion. Under the state’s Criminal Procedure Law ยง 140.10, an officer must make an arrest when there’s reasonable cause to believe a felony was committed against a member of the same family or household, when a known order of protection has been violated, or when a misdemeanor family offense was committed, unless the victim asks otherwise.
New York Focus reported that federal law bars people convicted of domestic violence from owning guns, which can make a conviction career-ending for a police officer. That’s a powerful incentive, and it’s one reason experts say departments must be careful about handling cases against their own.
The International Association of Chiefs of Police recommends that departments adopt zero-tolerance policies and discipline officers found to have committed domestic violence, up to termination, according to New York Focus.
03
Why the gun matters
The federal ban on gun ownership after a domestic violence conviction is meant to protect survivors. For a police officer, New York Focus reported, it can also end a career, because an officer who can’t carry a gun can’t do the job.
That creates pressure at every step. An arrest can lead to charges, charges can lead to a conviction, and a conviction can cost an officer the badge. The people deciding whether to make that arrest are often fellow officers. Even well-meaning colleagues can feel the weight of that outcome, and survivors can feel the pressure to stay quiet.
That’s why the details of how a department handles these cases matter so much. Mandatory arrest laws, outside investigations and clear discipline rules exist to take that pressure out of individual hands. When a department relies on its own judgment instead, the incentive to protect its own can win.
04
What the State Police say
A State Police spokesperson told New York Focus that the department has “zero tolerance for domestic violence or misconduct by its members.” The spokesperson said every allegation of domestic violence is taken seriously and investigated, and that the department’s handling of these complaints has changed over the years, according to the outlet’s November summary.
Bloom reports the department’s position because the public deserves to hear it. The records New York Focus obtained are the measure readers can hold it against.
05
When the investigators are colleagues
In at least eight domestic incidents, the State Police investigated their own employees, New York Focus reported. Experts told the outlet that referring such cases to outside agencies is typical practice.
That matters because an investigation is only as trustworthy as its independence. When the officers asking the questions work alongside the officer accused, survivors have reason to wonder whose side the system is on.
Mark Wynn, a former Nashville police lieutenant, used three words for what the files showed: “ignoring,” “enabling,” and “excusing,” New York Focus reported. “You can’t allow people, if they’re accused of a violent crime, to work on the street,” Wynn told the outlet.
06
When the abuser has a badge
The investigation found that several employees used police databases to track or harass survivors, New York Focus reported. In one case, a trooper ran the license plates of cars near his wife’s home and had a colleague look up a man she knew.
That’s what makes abuse by police officers different. An officer knows how emergency calls are handled, often knows the people who’ll respond, and has access to tools that can find a person who’s trying to hide. “This person has a gun. They have a badge, and they can use that authority,” one expert told New York Focus.
For a survivor, calling for help can mean calling the abuser’s coworkers. “It makes you feel like you don’t have anybody protecting you,” one survivor told New York Focus.
07
How New York Focus got the records
The files weren’t easy to get. Police discipline records in New York were confidential under state law until 2020, New York Focus reported. Its reporters gathered the documents over three years through public records requests and from other police departments and district attorneys, because the State Police resisted releasing discipline records, the outlet said.
The investigation was a collaboration with the nonprofit MuckRock, with support from the Fund for Investigative Journalism and the Data-Driven Reporting Project, according to New York Focus. Sammy Sussman and Annika Grosser contributed reporting.
The files have limits. They aren’t a complete record of every allegation, and they include only allegations the State Police substantiated, New York Focus reported. Cases the agency didn’t substantiate, or never investigated, aren’t in the count at all.
New York Focus also issued a correction on November 12, noting that its October story had misstated how many employees received censure or five or fewer days of suspension. Bloom uses the figures from the outlet’s November 16 summary.
08
Why this matters
Bloom’s Justice for Survivors desk reports on abuse by people in positions of trust and power. Few positions carry more power than a police officer’s. The same agency that’s supposed to protect survivors is, in these cases, the employer of the person accused.
This isn’t a story about one political side. It’s about police accountability: whether the people we trust to enforce the law are held to it. When a substantiated domestic violence finding leads to a few days of lost vacation, the message to survivors is that their safety counts for less than an officer’s career.
It’s also about public safety beyond one household. An officer who abuses a partner at home goes to work the next day with a gun and the authority to stop, search and arrest. How a department responds says something about who it believes the law protects.
09
A pattern in State Police discipline
The domestic violence files aren’t the first time New York Focus has looked at how the State Police discipline their own. In January, the outlet reported that loose rules let State Police hand out lax penalties for serious misconduct more broadly.
Taken together, the two investigations raise a question about police accountability that goes beyond any one case. If the rules give commanders wide room to choose light penalties, the outcome depends on who’s making the choice. Survivors, and the public, are left to hope for the best.
New York has already decided that the public has a right to see these records. In 2020, the state repealed the law known as Section 50-a, which had kept police discipline records secret. The New York Focus files exist because of that change, and because reporters spent years asking for them.
10
Why outside investigations matter
Experts told New York Focus that referring domestic violence cases against officers to outside agencies is typical. The reason is simple. People who work together, train together and depend on one another in dangerous moments find it hard to judge one another fairly, even when they try.
An outside investigator doesn’t remove every risk, but it changes the question a survivor has to ask. Instead of wondering whether her abuser’s friends will believe her, she can expect someone with no stake in his career to look at the facts. That’s what police accountability looks like in practice: the same rules, applied by someone independent, to the people who enforce them.
11
Questions for State Police leaders
The New York Focus findings leave questions that the State Police and state leaders can answer. Bloom will report the answers as they come.
- Will the State Police refer every domestic violence allegation against an employee to an outside agency?
- Will the department publish yearly data on domestic violence allegations against its employees and how each was resolved?
- How does the department decide when a substantiated finding leads to firing rather than a suspension?
- What has changed, specifically, in how these complaints are handled, as the department says?
Clear answers would help survivors decide whether to come forward, and help the public judge whether “zero tolerance” means what it says.
12
A timeline of the investigation
Here’s how the reporting unfolded, based on what New York Focus published.
- Before 2020: Police discipline records in New York are confidential under state law.
- 2014 to 2024: Most of the incidents in the files take place, with some dating to 1998.
- Three years of requests: Reporters gather records through public records requests, other departments and district attorneys.
- October 21, 2026: New York Focus publishes its investigation.
- November 12, 2026: The outlet corrects one figure in its original story.
- November 16, 2026: New York Focus publishes a guide to its findings.
13
If your abuser is a police officer
If someone hurting you works in law enforcement, you’re not imagining the extra danger, and you’re not alone. The National Domestic Violence Hotline answers at 800-799-7233, and you can text START to 88788. In New York, the state’s domestic and sexual violence hotline answers at 800-942-6906.
Advocates can help you make a safety plan that accounts for an abuser’s access to police tools and colleagues. You can ask for help from a different agency than the one your abuser works for, and you can report to the local district attorney’s office as well as to the department.
Keep a record when it’s safe to do so: dates, what happened, messages, and anyone who saw it. Store copies where your abuser can’t reach them.
Think about your phone and accounts. An abuser with police training may know how to track a device or a car. Check your phone’s location-sharing settings, change passwords from a device your abuser hasn’t touched, and ask an advocate about safety steps for your vehicle and accounts.
Ask an advocate or lawyer whether an order of protection in your case can require the surrender of firearms. When the abuser carries a gun for work, that question matters even more. A lawyer or advocate can help you seek an order of protection, and under New York law, an officer must arrest a person who violates a known order of protection.
14
What’s still unclear
It’s unclear how many domestic violence allegations against State Police employees were never substantiated, or never investigated, since those cases aren’t in the files New York Focus obtained.
It’s also unclear what specific changes the department says it has made to how it handles these complaints.
And it’s unclear whether the pattern is limited to the State Police. New York has hundreds of local police departments, each with its own discipline rules, and the files New York Focus obtained cover only one agency. Survivors whose abusers work for other departments face the same questions. Bloom will report any response from the State Police, the governor’s office or state lawmakers.
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom will keep reporting on how institutions treat survivors, especially when the person accused holds power. You can read more on our Justice for Survivors desk, including our report on the statute of limitations for survivors.
If today’s story stirred up something heavy, Bloom’s crisis support page lists more help, including 988 by call or text, RAINN at 800-656-4673, Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860 and The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386.
Bloom’s reporting runs on people who give a little every month. Become a monthly supporter, or give once if that fits your life better.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
It reviewed records on 18 State Police employees with substantiated domestic violence allegations. Most got censure or short suspensions, three faced arrest, and one was fired.
They were allegations the State Police investigated and substantiated, according to New York Focus. The files don’t include allegations the agency didn’t substantiate.
A spokesperson said the department has “zero tolerance for domestic violence or misconduct by its members” and that its handling of these complaints has changed over the years.
In many cases, yes. Under Criminal Procedure Law ยง 140.10, officers must arrest when there’s reasonable cause to believe certain family offenses occurred or an order of protection was violated.
Police discipline records in New York were confidential until 2020, and New York Focus said the State Police resisted releasing them, so reporters gathered them over three years.
No. Bloom is reporting the pattern the records show, not naming individuals.
The National Domestic Violence Hotline answers at 800-799-7233. In New York, call 800-942-6906. Advocates can help plan for an abuser’s access to police tools.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
New York Legislature · 16 November 2026New York Appeals Court Strikes Down Nassau County Trans Sports Ban
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026DOJ Official Behind Trans Care Subpoenas Resigns: What Stays
Justice for survivors · 17 November 2026Federal Prisons Closed Dublin, but Sexual Abuse of Women Didnโt Stop