A rusty padlock on a chain-link fence, for a report on a judge's ruling that ICE defied court orders

NewsroomColorado LegislatureNews

Judge Finds ICE Officials in Contempt Over Instant Re-Arrests

A federal judge in Colorado found ICE officials in contempt for re-arresting immigrants moments after court orders freed them. At least 18 people there were held too long or re-arrested within minutes in six weeks.

A federal judge in Colorado found Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials in contempt on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, for defying court orders. Federal judges had ordered immigrants released from detention, and ICE agents re-arrested some of them within minutes, sometimes after just a few steps. U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney wrote that the practice “made a mockery of court orders mandating petitioners’ immediate release.”

The judge imposed no penalty, because ICE stopped the re-arrests after she began asking questions. But her 15-page ruling is a warning, and it reaches beyond one man in one detention center. At least 18 people in Colorado were held longer than they should have been or re-arrested within minutes of a judge-ordered release in the past six weeks, Colorado Public Radio reported. Here is what happened, what the judge decided, and why court orders bind the government too.

01

What the judge decided

Judge Charlotte Sweeney found that ICE clearly violated court orders when agents re-arrested a man she had ordered released, Colorado Politics reported. She found an ICE official in contempt of court. And she stopped short of fines or other sanctions, because the government had already ended the practice.

“Given the (government) cured the contempt by ceasing the practice at issue, the court declines to take any further action,” she wrote, as CPR quoted the ruling. The “single thing” that saved Colorado ICE officials from penalties, she wrote, was the decision to rescind the policy after she began investigating. Her words left no doubt about what would happen if ICE ignored court orders again.

“Lest there be any confusion: All orders and judgments of courts must be complied with promptly,” Sweeney wrote. “This is neither a novel nor complex statement to comprehend.” She made clear that if ICE resumed the re-arrests, she wouldn’t hesitate to take the matter up again, CPR reported.

Contempt of court is how judges make their court orders mean something. Judges have broad powers when they hold someone in contempt, including fines or orders to stop a practice, CPR reported. This time the finding was a public rebuke from a co-equal branch of government, with the clear promise of more if ICE defies court orders again.

02

Released, then re-arrested in a few steps

The case before Judge Charlotte Sweeney began with Ramon Quintero Alvarez, a Wyoming man who had been held at the privately run detention center in Aurora, Colorado. He was born in Mexico and came to the United States with his mother between 1993 and 1994, and he hasn’t left the country since, CPR reported. He told the court he has lived in Wyoming for 12 years with his two American-born sons.

Alvarez filed a petition for habeas corpus, asking a federal court to free him from immigration detention. The U.S. Attorney’s Office didn’t file a response challenging it, which triggered his automatic release under a case-processing agreement the office had with the court at the time, Colorado Politics reported. The government didn’t dispute the facts of his case.

He was released on October 27, 2026, and immediately re-detained after he took a few steps, according to CPR and MPR News. In early November, a federal prosecutor told Sweeney that Alvarez had been released, re-detained and remained in custody. “It appears to me we have a problem of monumental importance,” she said at a hearing soon after. “This gentleman was ordered released, period.”

He wasn’t the only person re-arrested despite court orders. At the first hearing on November 4, the prosecutor said the man re-detained on October 27 was “at least the 10th in a week,” MPR News reported. “Releasing somebody momentarily is not releasing somebody at all,” Sweeney said that day.

03

An order to re-detain, and where it came from

Under oath, ICE officials struggled to say who had told agents to re-arrest people freed by court orders, and why. Nichole Black, an assistant ICE field office director for Denver, testified that she “received a direct order” from her supervisor to re-detain people released on habeas orders if they had some type of criminality, according to CPR and Colorado Politics.

Black believed Alvarez had a pending criminal charge. “But she was wrong,” Sweeney wrote. Black agreed she had inaccurate information about any current pending charge when she reviewed his case, Colorado Politics reported.

Her supervisor, acting field office director Nathan Rasper, told the judge Black’s account of his instruction was “overly compressed.” He said he hadn’t known about the court’s agreement with the U.S. Attorney’s Office, that he believed he had to “make lawful arrests,” and that he rescinded the directive after Sweeney began asking questions, according to the two outlets.

Rasper also testified that he directed the instant re-arrests after hearing that his ICE colleagues in Minnesota were doing the same, MPR News reported. Sweeney wasn’t persuaded that the blame stopped with one official. She described Rasper’s account as an effort to throw Black “under the proverbial bus for unconstitutional behavior that runs top to bottom.”

04

Why court orders bind the government

The core of the ruling is simple: when a federal court orders a person released, the government must release that person. Sweeney wrote that “not a single word in this Nation’s Constitution” supports the belief that agents “can walk out to the sidewalk and re-shackle a habeas petitioner within a minute of that petitioner’s court-ordered release.”

Black’s testimony that she thought she was complying with court orders should “shock any reader,” the judge wrote. “Sometimes, behavior stuns and renders a listener speechless,” she began one passage. She then turned to what the Supreme Court has said throughout the nation’s history: the government of the United States “has been emphatically termed a government of laws and not of men.”

“Our system of jurisprudence rests on the assumption that all individuals, whatever their position in government, are subject to federal law,” Sweeney said, citing a 1979 case. “No man is above the law.”

That principle protects everyone, citizen or not. Court orders are the way a person outside government holds power to account. If an agency can treat court orders as a formality, honored for a few steps and then undone, then the order means nothing, and neither does the right it was meant to protect.

05

What ICE says

ICE and the Department of Homeland Security didn’t immediately respond to Colorado Politics’ requests for comment on the ruling. The U.S. Attorney for Colorado, Peter McNeilly, had no comment on the order, CPR reported.

ICE has defended re-arrests in general. An ICE spokesperson for the agency’s Midwest office wrote that ICE will “take further action consistent with applicable law and court orders, which can include rearresting an offender,” MPR News reported. Earlier, another ICE spokesperson said that telling ICE it can’t seek a re-arrest is “nothing short of sabotage.”

Courts haven’t spoken with one voice. In Minnesota, two federal judges found instant re-arrests didn’t violate their court orders, and two others strongly disagreed, according to MPR News. An appeals court has yet to weigh in. In Colorado, Sweeney’s ruling makes clear where her court stands.

06

Other Colorado judges draw a line

Sweeney wasn’t the only judge defending court orders. Judge Philip A. Brimmer took the unusual step of telling ICE it may not re-arrest a habeas petitioner “without advance notice to this Court” that cites ICE’s legal authority to re-detain, Colorado Politics reported. Senior Judge R. Brooke Jackson said he would consider ICE employees in contempt if they re-arrested a petitioner.

In a Monday order, Jackson put it in plain words: release means “release and let go,” not release and rearrest. Separately, Judge Nina Y. Wang is looking into ICE’s practice of imposing conditions of release that judges haven’t ordered, Colorado Politics reported.

The pressure on the court is enormous. Habeas corpus petitions from people in immigration detention have surged to roughly 100 a week in Colorado’s federal district court, according to Colorado Politics. Each one is a person asking a judge for the most basic protection the law offers, and every release depends on ICE honoring court orders. For more than a year, the court has faced a flood of these petitions, pushing filings to unprecedented levels, Colorado Politics reported.

07

Habeas corpus, the check on unlawful detention

Habeas corpus lets a person in custody ask a federal court to order their release. For Alvarez, a writ of habeas corpus meant he could be released from detention while he fights his immigration case, CPR explained. In immigration cases, petitioners have used it to challenge denials of bond, the fairness of bond hearings and conditions ICE has placed on their release, Colorado Politics reported.

A habeas corpus petition only works if the government obeys the court orders that answer it. That’s why the Colorado judges reacted so sharply. Re-arresting someone moments after a release order turns a core protection against unlawful detention into a revolving door.

For families, the practical stakes are concrete. A release order is supposed to mean a parent comes home, a worker returns to a job, a person waits for their immigration case outside a cell. The Colorado ruling affirms that court orders mean exactly that.

08

A timeline of the Colorado case

These dates come from reporting by Colorado Public Radio, Colorado Politics and MPR News:

  • October 27, 2026: Alvarez is released under the court’s process and immediately re-detained.
  • November 3, 2026: A federal prosecutor tells Sweeney that Alvarez was re-detained and remains in custody.
  • November 4, 2026: Sweeney holds her first hearing; the prosecutor calls Alvarez “at least the 10th in a week.”
  • After November 4: Rasper says he stopped the re-arrests, and Sweeney orders a list of every re-arrest within 12 hours of a release since October 27.
  • November 9, 2026: At a second hearing, Rasper testifies that he followed what colleagues in Minnesota were doing.
  • November 16, 2026: Senior Judge R. Brooke Jackson writes that release means “release and let go.”
  • November 18, 2026: Sweeney finds ICE officials in contempt of court in a 15-page ruling.

09

Why this matters beyond Colorado

The government’s own list showed 14 people re-arrested within 12 hours of a court-ordered release in Colorado who had since been released again, MPR News reported, and the ACLU of Colorado told the court the list was likely an undercount. MPR News also confirmed at least eight men in Minnesota who were instantly re-arrested after federal judges ordered them released.

The Minnesota men had been brought to the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building for processing, MPR News reported. They signed release paperwork and were handed their belongings, and agents re-arrested them before they could leave federal property. One man was instantly re-arrested twice. Court orders that last only as long as a walk down a hallway don’t protect anyone.

Bloom has reported on the same pressure on due process across the country, from a class action over warrantless ICE arrests in Virginia to the sale of the Tacoma detention center in our own Pacific Northwest. Each story asks the same question this ruling answers: does the government have to follow the law when no one is watching?

Judge Charlotte Sweeney’s answer is yes. One district judge’s ruling doesn’t bind other courts, but its reasoning is now on the record for any judge to read. And it gives detained people and their lawyers a record to point to when court orders aren’t followed.

10

If someone you love is detained

If a family member is held in immigration detention, these steps can help you protect them:

  1. Find an immigration lawyer as soon as you can, and ask whether a habeas corpus petition in federal court fits the case.
  2. Keep copies of all court orders in the case, including any release order, and know the case number and the judge’s name.
  3. If your loved one is re-detained after a court orders them released, tell the lawyer right away, so the lawyer can bring it to the judge who issued the order.
  4. Write down what you see and hear: the date, the time, the place and the names of any officers.
  5. Take care of yourself and the people around you. Detention strains a whole family.

You aren’t powerless here. Judges in Colorado have shown they will enforce their court orders when they learn those orders are being ignored, and the record of a case gives them what they need to act.

11

What happens next

Sweeney declined to impose further sanctions because ICE ended the practice, but her ruling leaves the door open to more if re-arrests resume, CPR reported. Judge Nina Y. Wang’s inquiry into release conditions continues, and the other Colorado judges have set their own guardrails for re-arrests.

In Minnesota, the split among federal judges over instant re-arrests may eventually reach an appeals court. Bloom will keep following how the courts, and ICE, treat court orders across the country.

12

What Bloom is doing

Bloom stands for due process for every person, because rights that bend for some soon break for all. I believe a court’s word has to mean the same thing for a Wyoming father as it does for anyone in power. When the government ignores court orders, it isn’t only an immigrant who loses; it’s every one of us who counts on the courthouse door.

If this story weighs on you or your family, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups are there when you want company. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

A monthly gift keeps Bloom watching the courts, week after week, and a one-time gift helps too.

13

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 18, 2026, U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney found ICE officials in contempt for defying court orders by re-arresting a man moments after his release. She imposed no sanctions because ICE ended the practice.

Contempt of court is a judge’s finding that someone disobeyed court orders. Judges can respond with fines or orders to stop the conduct, and here the judge warned of more if ICE resumes the re-arrests.

The case involved Ramon Quintero Alvarez, a Wyoming man held in Aurora, Colorado, who was re-detained moments after his release on October 27. At least 18 people in Colorado were held too long or re-arrested within minutes in six weeks, CPR reported.

Habeas corpus lets a person in custody ask a federal court to order their release. In immigration cases, a writ can let a person leave detention while they fight their immigration case.

An ICE official testified that she received a direct order to re-detain people with some type of criminality, and her supervisor said he followed what ICE colleagues in Minnesota were doing. He told the judge he stopped the practice after her first hearing.

Tell their lawyer right away so the lawyer can bring it to the judge who issued the order. Keep copies of all court orders, and write down the date, time, place and names of any officers involved.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.