
Newsroom·Arizona Legislature·News
Survivors Ask Supreme Court: Who Decides What Clergy Must Report?
Arizona's top court ruled that judges and juries generally can't second-guess clergy who keep an abuse disclosure confidential under their church's doctrine.
Three Arizona siblings whose abuse went unreported for years, after their abuser admitted abuse to leaders of his church, have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take their case. Their petition, No. 26-651, asks whether the First Amendment lets church doctrine, rather than a court or jury, decide when a clergy member may stay silent under Arizona’s clergy exemption from child abuse reporting.
In July, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled 7-0 that judges and juries generally can’t second-guess how a clergy member applies his own faith’s doctrine when he decides that withholding a report is “reasonable and necessary.” That ruling ended the siblings’ lawsuit against The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and two men who served as local bishops. A response is due December 18. Here’s what the clergy exemption says, what Arizona’s court decided, what the justices could do next, how Oregon and Washington treat clergy, and how to report abuse wherever you live.
01
The seven questions about the clergy exemption
The petition was filed by John Trebon, the siblings’ counsel of record, with Lynne M. Cadigan and John C. Manly. The Supreme Court’s docket lists it as filed November 16 and docketed November 18. In its own words, cut short, the petition asks:
- Whether “a neutral child abuse reporting statute” becomes unconstitutional when it makes clergy report abuse learned through “communications that are not in fact confidential.”
- Whether the First Amendment compels such a law to be “judicially altered or amended to exempt clergy members.”
- Whether clergy are excused “because Church doctrine provides that the communication should be confidential,” even when it wasn’t.
- Whether using churches “as an arm of the civil judiciary” to apply state law violates the Establishment Clause.
- Whether “Church doctrine, rather than a court or jury,” decides what counts as a confession or a confidential communication.
- Whether confidentiality is a question of fact, or one “decided by normative Church doctrine.”
- “Did the Arizona Supreme Court apply First Amendment principles correctly?”
A petition for a writ of certiorari asks the justices to hear a case. It isn’t a ruling, and nothing about Arizona’s clergy exemption changes unless the Court takes the case and decides it.
02
How the clergy exemption case began
The facts below come from the Arizona Supreme Court’s opinion, which the petition reprints in full. Around 2011, a member of a Latter-day Saints congregation in Cochise County met privately with his bishop and disclosed that he had abused one of his children. The bishop then met with the man and his wife, and he disclosed it again.
In 2012, a new bishop took over the congregation, learned of the disclosures, and convened a church disciplinary council. The man disclosed the abuse again there and was excommunicated. Neither bishop reported to police, KVOA reported.
In 2017, after the Department of Homeland Security found evidence of the abuse, criminal charges followed, the opinion says. Three of the children, now plaintiffs known only as Jane Doe I, Jane Doe II and John Doe, sued the church, the two bishops and the bishops’ wives, acting through a conservator, the Tucson law firm Fleming & Curti PLC. Their claims, including negligence, rested in part on the bishops’ failure to report under Arizona law. The church defendants argued that the clergy exemption applied, and in November 2023 the Cochise County Superior Court agreed, granting them summary judgment.
Bloom names no one in the family. The children’s privacy matters more than any headline.
03
What Arizona’s clergy exemption says
Arizona’s reporting law, A.R.S. 13-3620, requires the people it lists to “immediately report” a reasonable belief that a child has been abused, to police or the Department of Child Safety. The list includes doctors, nurses, school staff and parents, along with members of the clergy, priests and Christian Science practitioners.
Then comes the clergy exemption. A member of the clergy who receives “a confidential communication or a confession” in that role, “in the course of the discipline enjoined by the church,” may withhold reporting it if he decides that’s “reasonable and necessary within the concepts of the religion.” The clergy exemption covers only the communication itself, and not “personal observations” a clergy member makes of the child.
The stakes are real. Under subsection S, failing to report is a class 1 misdemeanor, or a class 6 felony when the failure involves a reportable offense. That’s why the clergy exemption decides who can be held to account, in criminal court and in civil suits like this one.
04
What the Arizona Supreme Court decided
Vice Chief Justice John R. Lopez IV wrote the opinion on July 30, 2026, and all seven justices joined it. It made three holdings about the clergy exemption.
First, when clergy invoke the clergy exemption, “the First Amendment generally prohibits factfinders from inquiring into a clergy member’s application of his particular religious doctrine” when deciding whether withholding a report was reasonable and necessary. The one exception is fraud or collusion for secular purposes.
Second, the court defined both key terms. A confession is a confidential admission of “a crime, sin, or fault” to clergy “for the purpose of absolution.” A confidential communication is speech treated as private and meant only for the people addressed. But under the clergy exemption, courts must give “substantial deference to a religious institution’s own doctrinal conception” of both.
Third, a religious body decides who counts as clergy, and courts can’t question that absent fraud or collusion. The court also held that the penitent’s privilege in a separate statute is irrelevant to the duty to report, and it disavowed a 1988 appeals decision to the extent it blended those privileges with the clergy exemption.
05
How church doctrine settled the facts
Applying those rules to the clergy exemption, the court accepted the church’s account of its own teaching: bishops have a solemn duty to keep confessions confidential, and that duty extends to everyone on a disciplinary council. It held that the man’s admissions, alone with the bishop, with his wife present and before the council, were all confessions or confidential communications. Any further inquiry, it said, “is explicitly doctrinal.”
The appeals court had pointed to a church handbook rule requiring disclosure when necessary to prevent serious injury. The Supreme Court said that rule was added after these events, and that weighing it would intrude on doctrine. The court said it was “constrained to credit” the bishops’ judgment that withholding a report was reasonable and necessary.
So it vacated the appeals court’s decision and reinstated summary judgment for the church defendants. Under the clergy exemption as the court read it, no jury would ever hear the case.
06
What the survivors’ lawyers argue
The petition’s core claim is that Arizona’s statute, clergy exemption included, is neutral, and that the First Amendment didn’t require rewriting it. It says the bishop told the man’s wife to report his second admission to police, and that she testified in a deposition that the conversation wasn’t confidential. In the petition’s view, whether words were actually spoken in confidence is a fact a jury can weigh.
It also invokes a 1969 Supreme Court case holding that the “First Amendment prohibits a State from employing religious organizations as an arm of the civil judiciary” to interpret state standards. Letting doctrine decide confidentiality under the clergy exemption, the petition argues, does exactly that.
The petition says the ruling creates an “intolerable division amongst states.” It names New Jersey, Alabama, Missouri, California, Colorado, Virginia, Illinois and Maryland as places where courts test confidentiality by objective reasonableness. It says the Arizona court never discussed the 1990 case holding that neutral, generally applicable laws don’t violate the Free Exercise Clause.
“The Arizona statute was intended to protect our children,” the petition concludes. Cadigan, quoted by KVOA, called the case a chance for the Court “to make clear that freedom of religion does not mean freedom to conceal” child abuse. Manly said, “We must now look to the United States Supreme Court to throw these vulnerable children a lifeline.”
07
What the church and the Arizona court say
The church hasn’t filed its response yet. In a statement to Arizona’s Family in September, church spokesman Doug Anderson said, “The abuse of a child or any person is a tragic betrayal of trust.” He added, “Arizona law also recognizes the confidential nature of religious confession.”
“The court’s decision affirms that these religious protections are to be respected alongside society’s shared commitment to protect the vulnerable,” Anderson said. The statement also said the church encourages reporting through safeguarding efforts.
The Arizona court addressed the fear of immunity itself. It said its reading of the clergy exemption doesn’t give religious institutions “a general immunity from secular laws,” and that a court may still look for fraud or collusion. It also said the statute’s secular purpose, “promoting the welfare of children,” remains intact. On the wife’s presence, it noted that the bishop had asked the man’s permission to report, citing confidentiality. The petition notes that the church’s lawyer conceded at argument that judges have “some role” in deciding whether a confession happened at all.
08
A timeline of the clergy exemption case
These dates come from the opinion, the petition, the docket and KVOA:
- Around 2011: A congregation member discloses abuse to his bishop, then again with his wife present.
- 2012: A new bishop convenes a disciplinary council; the man is excommunicated.
- 2017: Federal investigators find evidence; criminal charges follow.
- November 3, 2023: The Cochise County Superior Court grants summary judgment to the church defendants.
- July 29, 2025: The Arizona Court of Appeals reverses, finding disputed facts for a jury.
- July 30, 2026: The Arizona Supreme Court rules 7-0 for the church defendants.
- August 21, 2026: It denies the siblings’ motion for reconsideration.
- November 16, 2026: The petition is filed; it’s docketed November 18.
- December 18, 2026: A response is due.
KVOA dated the Arizona ruling to August. The opinion is dated July 30; August 21 is when reconsideration was denied.
09
What happens next at the Supreme Court
The respondents can file a brief in opposition within 30 days of docketing, unless the time is extended, or waive one, under the Court’s Rule 15. Once a brief is filed, the clerk sends the papers to the justices at least 14 days later, giving the siblings time to reply. With a waiver, the petition goes straight to the justices.
Review is “not a matter of right, but of judicial discretion,” Rule 10 says, and is granted “only for compelling reasons.” One listed reason is a state supreme court splitting from another state’s high court on an important federal question. That’s why the petition leans on New Jersey.
Four of the nine justices must vote to take a case, and the Court accepts 100 to 150 of the more than 7,000 cases it’s asked to review each year, according to the federal judiciary. If it grants review, the case is set for briefing and argument. If it denies review, the Arizona ruling stands, and so does Arizona’s reading of its clergy exemption.
10
Where other states draw the clergy exemption line
Arizona isn’t alone in writing a clergy exemption into its mandatory reporting law. Thirty-three states have some kind of clergy exception in mandatory reporting, and six have removed it: New Hampshire, North Carolina, Oklahoma, West Virginia, Rhode Island and Texas, Arizona’s Family reported.
Arizona’s lawmakers have been asked to revisit theirs. Cadigan helped draft a bill to amend the state’s mandatory reporting statute, SB 1235, and its Senate sponsors told Arizona’s Family it couldn’t get out of committee.
That’s why the petition matters beyond one family. A clergy exemption is written by each state’s legislature, but the First Amendment limits all of them. If the justices take this case, their answer about the clergy exemption would shape how every state’s courts read their own.
11
How Oregon’s clergy exemption works
In Oregon, a member of the clergy is a “public or private official” under ORS 419B.005, and ORS 419B.010 requires officials with reasonable cause to “immediately report” abuse. Oregon’s clergy exemption works through privilege instead: clergy needn’t report information communicated by a person if it’s privileged under the evidence code.
That privilege, ORS 40.260, defines a confidential communication as “a communication made privately and not intended for further disclosure except to other persons present in furtherance of the purpose of the communication.” Its definition of clergy turns on a duty to keep such communications secret.
Two more lines matter for every congregation. “The duty to report under this section is personal to the public or private official alone,” ORS 419B.010 says, and it exists regardless of an organization’s own internal reporting procedures. Failing to report is a Class A violation.
12
Washington’s clergy exemption and the confession case
Washington added clergy to its list of mandatory reporters in 2025, and on paper its statute gives clergy no privilege exemption at all. RCW 26.44.030 requires a report “at the first opportunity, but in no case longer than 48 hours” after reasonable cause arises. It also says that, except for clergy, no one has to report information learned solely through a privileged communication. RCW 26.44.020 defines clergy broadly, from ministers and priests to rabbis, imams and elders.
The statute’s text isn’t the whole picture. In July 2025, a federal court blocked enforcement of the law “as to the Sacrament of Confession,” Attorney General Nick Brown said in a statement quoted by FOX 13 Seattle.
On October 10, 2025, the Attorney General’s Office announced stipulations: clergy remain mandatory reporters, but the state and county prosecutors agreed “not to enforce reporting requirements for information clergy learn solely through confession or its equivalent in other faiths.” The stipulations then awaited the court’s approval.
13
What faith communities can do now
Faith communities hold confession as holy, and Bloom honors that. The same faith calls every shepherd to protect the smallest ones in the fold. Those two callings don’t have to collide when leaders know the law where they serve.
Learn your state’s clergy exemption before you need it. In Arizona, it doesn’t cover a clergy member’s own observations of a child. In Oregon, the duty is personal, and a church’s internal reporting rules don’t replace it. In Washington, abuse clergy learn of outside confession or its equivalent must be reported within 48 hours.
When a child’s safety is at stake, ask whether a report can be made, not only whether it must be. The church in this case says it encourages reporting through safeguarding, and Seattle’s archbishop has written that archdiocese policy requires priests to direct those who confess to self-report or seek counseling, FOX 13 reported. Bloom has followed how churches answer survivors, from Rhode Island’s clergy abuse lawsuits to the Oakland diocese verdict.
14
How to report suspected child abuse
Arizona, Oregon and Washington ask reporters for a reasonable belief or reasonable cause, not proof, and the clergy exemption applies only to clergy, not to you. If a child is in immediate danger, call 911. Otherwise:
- Arizona: Arizona Child Abuse Hotline, 1-888-SOS-CHILD (1-888-767-2445), from the Department of Child Safety.
- Oregon: Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233), for abuse of a child or adult, from the Oregon Department of Human Services.
- Washington: 866-363-4276 on evenings, weekends and holidays, with regional numbers on the DCYF reporting page.
- Anywhere in the U.S.: the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline, (800) 422-4453, by call or text.
- Adult survivors: RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline, 800-656-4673.
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with survivors of child sexual abuse and with every faith community that chooses to protect children first. Bloom will follow Docket No. 26-651 through the December 18 response and the justices’ decision, as it followed the Baltimore archdiocese settlement this week. I believe a confession can be sacred and a child’s safety can be sacred too, and the law should never force a church to choose against the child.
If this story stirs old pain, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading court records for survivors, and a one-time gift helps too.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
It’s the part of A.R.S. 13-3620 that lets clergy withhold reporting a confession or confidential communication if they decide that’s reasonable and necessary within their religion. It doesn’t cover what clergy personally observe.
On July 30, 2026, it ruled 7-0 that courts and juries generally can’t question how clergy apply their own doctrine, and must defer to a church’s view of what’s confidential, absent fraud or collusion.
It asks seven First Amendment questions, chiefly whether church doctrine, rather than a court or jury, decides what counts as a confession or confidential communication under a neutral reporting law.
A response is due December 18, 2026. The justices consider the petition after that, and four of nine must vote to hear it.
Yes. Oregon lists clergy as officials who must report abuse immediately, except for information privileged under the clergy-penitent rule, ORS 40.260.
Washington’s statute lists clergy as reporters, but a federal court blocked enforcement as to confession, and the state agreed not to enforce reporting of information learned solely through confession or its equivalent.
Call 911 if a child is in danger. In Arizona, call 1-888-SOS-CHILD; in Oregon, 855-503-SAFE; in Washington, 866-363-4276; anywhere in the U.S., Childhelp at (800) 422-4453.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Arizona Legislature · 14 November 2026Appeals Court Revives ADA Challenge to Sedonaโs Car-Sleeping Ban
Missouri Legislature · 20 November 2026Mizzou Student Group Sues AG Over Demand for Member, Donor Names
New York Legislature · 20 November 2026Liverpool Students Walk Out Over Rule to Tell Parents About Gender