
Newsroom·Virginia Legislature·News
Judge Orders ICE to Keep Princeton Student Eva Yi Xie in Virginia
A federal judge has ordered ICE to keep Eva Yi Xie, a Princeton Ph.D. student with a pending asylum case, in Virginia while he decides whether her detention is lawful. The government must answer by 5 PM Wednesday.
Eva Yi Xie went to Washington to share her research and didn’t come home. Immigration agents detained the Princeton University neuroscience Ph.D. student at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport on Thursday afternoon, November 19, 2026, as she left the Society for Neuroscience’s annual meeting, The Daily Princetonian reported. Her lawyer says she has an asylum application pending and a court date in January 2028.
The next day, a federal judge in Alexandria ordered that she stay in the Eastern District of Virginia while he decides whether ICE can lawfully hold her. That order keeps Eva Yi Xie within reach of her lawyers and the court. It also places her case inside a question that has split the federal appeals courts: whether people already living in the U.S. can be held under mandatory detention, with no bond hearing at all. The government’s answer is due at 5:00 PM on Wednesday, November 25.
01
Eva Yi Xie’s case at a glance
- Who: Eva Yi Xie, 24, a third-year neuroscience Ph.D. student at Princeton who came to the U.S. from China in March 2016, at 14.
- Where: Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in Arlington, Virginia, on November 19.
- The case: Yi Xie v. Robert Guadian, No. 1:26-cv-03839, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.
- The order: ICE may not remove her from the judicial district “pending further order of the Court.”
- The deadlines: the government by 5:00 PM on November 25; her reply, if one is needed, by 5:00 PM on November 30.
- Where she is now: the Caroline Detention Facility in Bowling Green, Virginia, according to ICE’s detainee locator on Saturday.
- Her immigration case: an asylum application her lawyer says was filed within a year of her arrival, now before an immigration court.
02
What happened at Reagan National Airport
Eva Yi Xie had presented a poster at the conference on Wednesday, November 18, the Prince, as the paper is known, reported. On Thursday, as she prepared to board a domestic flight, she was taken into ICE custody. “On Nov 19, Eva sent a call for help to her lab mates on Slack, then we lost contact,” her lab wrote in a social media post quoted by ABC7 New York.
The Department of Homeland Security told Newsweek that it carried out a targeted enforcement operation at Reagan National that day to arrest Eva Yi Xie. ICE first held her at a holding center in Chantilly, Virginia. Her lawyer, Kerry Doyle, told the Prince that holding centers like it lack readily accessible beds and showers, and she called holding people there for long periods “completely inhumane.”
On Saturday morning, November 21, ICE’s detainee locator showed that Eva Yi Xie had been moved to the Caroline Detention Facility in Bowling Green, Virginia, the Prince reported. NBC News reported the same location from a detainee search on ICE’s website.
03
What the judge ordered for Eva Yi Xie
Eva Yi Xie’s lawyers filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus on Friday, November 20, the court docket shows. Habeas corpus is the centuries-old legal tool for asking a judge one question: is this person being held lawfully? The petition alleges she “is being unlawfully held at the Chantilly ICE Holding Facility,” the judge’s order says.
That same day, U.S. District Judge Anthony J. Trenga signed a two-page order. The officials she named, and everyone acting with them, are “ENJOINED from removing the Petitioner from this judicial district pending further order of the Court.”
The order gives the government two choices by 5:00 PM on November 25. It can file a notice saying the issues “do not differ in any material fashion” from two earlier decisions, Hernandez and Lopez Garcia, or the opinions they cite. If it does, “this Court will issue a ruling without further filings from the parties.” Or it can file an opposition explaining the differences.
An opposition must attach “all relevant documentation surrounding the Petitioner’s immigration history, detention, and removal proceedings.” Eva Yi Xie’s lawyers would then have until 5:00 PM on November 30 to reply. A government lawyer appeared on November 20 for three of the officials she named, including Robert Guadian, named in the Fourth Circuit’s September opinion as director of ICE’s Washington Field Office.
04
Why a no-transfer order matters
A habeas petition asks a court to act for a person in its reach. When that person is moved far away, lawyers lose time and families lose contact. During the current administration, ICE “has frequently moved detainees away from the districts in which they were detained,” the Prince reported, and Judge Trenga’s order prohibits that in Eva Yi Xie’s case.
This isn’t a special rule for a famous student. In September 2025, the same judge entered the same kind of order in a habeas case brought by a Salvadoran man held at the Farmville Detention Center, that docket shows. It’s a way the court keeps the person within its reach while the law is argued.
The Saturday move didn’t break the order. Bowling Green is in Caroline County, which the court’s own list of cities and counties places in its Richmond Division. Due process is more than a phrase in the Fifth Amendment. It’s a lawyer who can reach you, a judge who can see you, and a family that knows where you are.
05
What mandatory detention means
Two parts of federal immigration law decide whether a person held during a removal case can ask to go home. Under Section 1226(a), a person can get a bond hearing, where an immigration judge decides whether they’re a danger or a flight risk. Under Section 1225(b)(2)(A), there’s no bond hearing at all.
For decades, people already living in the U.S. were held under Section 1226(a). In July 2025, ICE issued interim guidance treating those who had entered without inspection as subject to mandatory detention instead, and the Board of Immigration Appeals adopted that reading, the Fourth Circuit explained in September.
Judge Trenga’s order says Eva Yi Xie’s petition is “materially identical to those presented in other recently filed and adjudicated habeas petitions.” Those petitions address “the propriety of mandatory detention pursuant to 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b),” the order says.
For a long-pending asylum applicant, which section applies can decide whether there’s any hearing on release at all. In the earlier case Judge Trenga cited, an immigration judge decided the immigration court had no jurisdiction to set bond because of the board’s decision. When the immigration court’s door is shut, a federal habeas case may be the only one left.
06
The cases the judge pointed to
The order names two decisions. The first is Hernandez v. Crawford, decided by Judge Trenga himself on October 16, 2025.
In that case, a man who entered the country in 2017 was arrested in Washington in August 2025. He was held at an ICE field office in Chantilly for two days, then moved to Farmville. An immigration judge said the court had no jurisdiction to issue a bond.
Judge Trenga ruled that his detention was governed by Section 1226(a), not Section 1225(b). The judge wrote that the man “is entitled to a bond hearing before an Immigration Judge.” He ordered that hearing within seven days and barred the government from using an automatic stay if bond was granted.
The men in both cases the order cites entered the country without inspection. DHS says Eva Yi Xie was admitted in 2016. The order leaves it to the government to say whether that, or anything else, makes her case different.
07
How the Fourth Circuit ruled in September
The second decision binds every federal court in Virginia, including the one hearing Eva Yi Xie’s petition. In Lopez Garcia v. Guadian, decided September 10, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 for two men who had lived in the U.S. for decades.
The court held that Section 1226 applies to noncitizens who “have been present in the United States for years regardless of how they entered our country.” The two men “could not be detained pending the outcome of their removal proceedings without the opportunity to argue for their release at a bond hearing,” the court wrote.
The opinion counts eight circuits on that side and two, the Fifth and Eighth, on the government’s. It says more than five hundred federal district courts had rejected the government’s reading in more than twenty thousand cases.
Judge Rushing dissented, writing that Section 1225(b)(2)(A) “requires DHS to detain aliens who are present in the country without having been lawfully admitted.”
08
What Eva Yi Xie’s lawyers say
Doyle, whose representation Princeton arranged, told the Prince that Eva Yi Xie’s parents applied for asylum on her behalf within a year of arriving, in line with the legal deadline. The case was later referred to immigration court, where she has a date in January 2028. Doyle said she also has a valid work permit.
“Her arrest and detention is without legal basis as ICE and DHS are fully aware,” Doyle told NBC News. She said people with pending asylum cases “have permission to be here” while their cases are decided.
Doyle told the Prince on Friday that the habeas petition argues ICE arrested Eva Yi Xie without a warrant, and that nothing about her circumstances made a warrantless arrest necessary. NBC reported that she argued Xie was not a flight risk or a danger to the community. The Prince reported that Doyle served as a principal legal adviser for ICE and as deputy general counsel of DHS during the Biden administration.
09
What DHS says
DHS says Eva Yi Xie is in the country unlawfully. In a statement to the Prince, a spokesperson wrote that she was “admitted to the United States on a temporary basis on March 16, 2016.” DHS said she broke the law by “refusing to depart by the required date of September 15, 2016.”
“Xie has NEVER held valid authorization to study in the United States,” the statement said, according to ABC7 and NBC. It added, “To be clear, a pending application does not confer legal status in the United States.”
DHS told Newsweek that “Xie will receive due process and remain in ICE custody pending her removal proceedings.” It said it is working to ensure that people it says are here illegally “can no longer fly unless it is out of our country to self-deport.”
10
What the record doesn’t show yet
The habeas petition itself isn’t public; the docket lists it, but the document isn’t available. The Prince wrote that it’s not clear what visa Eva Yi Xie entered on, whether her family applied for asylum before or after their visas expired, or the reasons for the claim. Doyle said she doesn’t yet have all of Xie’s immigration papers.
Bloom won’t guess at any of it. Whether her asylum claim succeeds is for an immigration judge to decide, and the habeas case doesn’t ask that question.
Not having legal status doesn’t automatically mean a person is unlawfully present, the Prince explained. Citing U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, it reported that minors under 18 don’t accrue unlawful status, and that time spent with a pending “bona fide asylum application” generally isn’t considered unlawful presence. And generally, asylum applicants can’t be deported until an immigration judge rules on their case, the Prince reported.
11
Pending asylum applicants are being stopped at airports
Eva Yi Xie’s arrest wasn’t the first of its kind. ICE and the Transportation Security Administration formally agreed in May 2025 to share information about certain travelers, the Prince reported. Some immigration lawyers now advise people with pending applications not to fly domestically.
The ACLU’s airport guide says ICE arrested more than 800 people at airports from the start of the president’s second term through February 2026. It lists people with an expired visa who have filed another immigration application among those at particular risk.
Eva Yi Xie’s case echoes others. On October 30, a UC Berkeley student with a pending asylum case and a work permit was detained at San Francisco International Airport while waiting for a flight to Portland, Oregon, the Prince reported. She was released on November 9 after her lawyers argued she’d had no chance to challenge her detention in court. And on Saturday, officers arrested two passengers on a Sea-Tac jet bridge, as Bloom reported.
12
A timeline of Eva Yi Xie’s detention
- March 16, 2016: DHS says she was admitted on a temporary basis.
- September 15, 2016: the departure date DHS says she missed.
- Within a year of arrival: her parents applied for asylum, her lawyer says.
- July 2025: ICE issues interim guidance expanding mandatory detention.
- October 16, 2025: Judge Trenga decides Hernandez v. Crawford.
- September 10, 2026: the Fourth Circuit decides Lopez Garcia v. Guadian.
- November 19, 2026: ICE detains her at Reagan National Airport.
- November 20: her lawyers file for habeas corpus, and the judge bars her removal from the district.
- November 21: ICE’s locator shows her at the Caroline Detention Facility.
- November 25, 5:00 PM: the government’s notice or opposition is due.
- November 30, 5:00 PM: her reply is due if the government opposes.
- January 2028: her immigration court date.
13
Who this reaches
Eva Yi Xie’s case reaches anyone who has done what the law asked and is still waiting for an answer. People with pending asylum claims, expired visas and work permits live, work and study here for years while their cases wait.
It reaches students, too. Princeton’s graduate school dean, Rodney D. Priestley, said the university arranged legal counsel for Eva Yi Xie. “We hope Eva will soon be able to resume her studies at Princeton,” he said.
Her adviser, Princeton neuroscience professor Carlos Brody, put it simply. “She belongs back home in Princeton doing the science that she loves,” he told The Transmitter.
14
What happens next
The government has until 5:00 PM on Wednesday, November 25, to either concede that Eva Yi Xie’s case matches the earlier ones or explain why it doesn’t. If it concedes, the judge will rule without more briefing. In Hernandez, a ruling for the petitioner meant a bond hearing within seven days.
If the government opposes, it must file Eva Yi Xie’s immigration records, and her lawyers reply by November 30. Either way, ICE can’t move her out of the district until the court says otherwise.
Her immigration case goes on separately, with its January 2028 date. Student groups and local organizations planned an “emergency rally” for Monday at Princeton’s Robertson Hall plaza, the Prince reported. Bloom will report the judge’s ruling when it comes.
15
What you can do if you have a pending case and need to travel
These steps draw on the ACLU and the federal immigration courts. They aren’t legal advice for your case.
- Weigh the risk before you book. “Certain noncitizens should consider the risks of flying, including on domestic flights within the US,” the ACLU warns.
- Talk to a lawyer first. “Noncitizens who feel uncertain regarding their own risks should consult an attorney, if able to do so,” the ACLU says.
- Know your A-Number and your court date. Call 1-800-898-7180 to get immigration court case status information “24 hours a day, 7 days a week,” the Executive Office for Immigration Review says.
- Carry your lawyer’s number. Make sure someone you trust knows your flight and has your A-Number.
- Stay silent and sign nothing. “Don’t say anything, sign anything, or make any decisions without a lawyer,” the ACLU’s immigrants’ rights guide says.
- Ask for a bond hearing. If you’re denied release, the ACLU says, “ask for a bond hearing before an immigration judge.”
16
If someone you love is detained
First, find them. Search the ICE Online Detainee Locator System. That’s where Eva Yi Xie’s transfer to Caroline showed up on Saturday morning.
Then find free legal help fast, before a transfer. The Amica Center for Immigrant Rights says, “We work with current or previous residents of the Capital area who are currently in detention.” Its intake form lists Caroline and Farmville. Its Detained Adult Program also provides court-appointed lawyers for detained people with mental health conditions or developmental disabilities.
Outside the region, the National Immigration Legal Services Directory searches by detention facility. “Only nonprofit organizations that provide free or low-cost immigration legal services are included in this directory,” it says. The immigration courts also publish a list of pro bono legal service providers.
“If you are detained, you have the right to call a lawyer or your family,” the ACLU says. Members of Congress can ask ICE questions too. One New Jersey senator’s office told the Prince it had contacted ICE about Eva Yi Xie, and the other’s said it was working on her case.
17
What Bloom is doing
Bloom has followed what happens when ICE meets the courts. This week a judge found ICE officials in contempt for re-arresting people moments after they were freed. Another judge freed an 18-year-old seized without a warrant in Maine, and a third ordered the release of a Willmar man detained after he sought help.
Bloom also reported on a class action over warrantless ICE arrests in Virginia and an appeals court’s pause in a third-country deportation case. I believe due process belongs to every person on this soil, and a court that can still see you is a promise worth keeping.
If fear is heavy tonight, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call, and 988 answers by call or text. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps this reporting steady, and a one-time gift helps too.
18
Frequently Asked Questions
Eva Yi Xie is a third-year neuroscience Ph.D. student at Princeton University who came to the U.S. from China in 2016, at 14. ICE detained her at Reagan National Airport on November 19, 2026.
DHS says she was admitted temporarily in 2016 and stayed past her September 15, 2016 departure date. Her lawyer says she has a pending asylum application, a work permit and an immigration court date in January 2028.
On November 20, Judge Anthony J. Trenga barred ICE from removing Eva Yi Xie from the Eastern District of Virginia while he decides her habeas corpus petition. The government must respond by 5:00 PM on November 25.
On Saturday, November 21, ICE’s locator showed Eva Yi Xie at the Caroline Detention Facility in Bowling Green, Virginia, which is inside the court’s district.
It’s detention with no bond hearing. The government reads Section 1225(b) to require it for many people already in the U.S., and the Fourth Circuit rejected that reading for long-time residents in September 2026.
Yes. A pending application doesn’t stop ICE from arresting someone, but a person in custody can challenge the detention, and the ACLU advises asking for a bond hearing.
In D.C., Maryland and Virginia, the Amica Center for Immigrant Rights works with detained residents. Elsewhere, the National Immigration Legal Services Directory searches by detention facility.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Legislation · 21 November 2026ICE Arrests Two Passengers on Sea-Tac Jet Bridge, Delaying Flight
New York Legislature · 22 November 2026Nursing Aide Admits Sexually Assaulting 2 Residents, One With Dementia
Nebraska Legislature · 22 November 2026Nebraska Medicaid Will Charge Copays and Cap Therapy Sessions in 2027