The white clock tower and pediment of the Missoula County Courthouse against a deep blue sky, where a judge blocked Montana's SB 437

NewsroomMontana LegislatureNews

Montana Judge Blocks SB 437, the Law Defining Sex as Binary

Montana can't enforce SB 437, its law defining sex as binary across 64 sections of state code, while transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans challenge it. A judge found it likely unconstitutional.

Transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans won a pause this week in a state law that defines sex as binary across the Montana Code. Missoula County District Judge Leslie Halligan blocked the state from enforcing SB 437 while their lawsuit against it goes on, finding they are likely to show the law violates the privacy and equal protection guarantees of the Montana Constitution, Montana Free Press reported.

The order means state officers, agents and employees can’t apply SB 437’s definitions of “sex,” “male,” “female,” “gender” and related words while the case is decided. Those definitions reach driver’s license and marriage license applications, vital records, the Montana Human Rights Act and dozens of other laws. The state has said it will defend the law. Here is what SB 437 says, what the ruling changes for your IDs and records, what each side argues, and what comes next.

01

What the SB 437 injunction does

The order is short where it counts. “The PI is HEREBY GRANTED,” Halligan wrote, and the state, its officers and employees “are temporarily restrained from enforcing the definitions contained in SB 437 pending final adjudication of this case.” She also waived the bond the plaintiffs would normally have to post.

A preliminary injunction is not a final ruling. It holds things in place while a court decides the case on a full record. In Halligan’s words, it “simply preserves the pre-SB 437 legal framework while the case proceeds.”

The order carries a Missoula County filing stamp of November 16, 2026, and Halligan’s electronic signature from that Monday morning. Upper Seven Law, which represents the plaintiffs, dates it November 17, and Montana Free Press and the Daily Montanan reported it as granted on Tuesday.

02

Who brought the case against SB 437

The plaintiffs are a group of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans, Montana Free Press reported. One of them is an organization, the Montana Two Spirit Society, which the court found has standing to sue on behalf of its members. Bloom does not name the individual plaintiffs.

They are represented by Upper Seven Law, a Helena firm. The defendants are the State of Montana, Gov. Greg Gianforte and Attorney General Austin Knudsen.

This is not a new lawsuit. The same plaintiffs sued in 2023 over SB 458, the earlier law defining sex, and won. When SB 437 became law in March, they asked the court to add it to their case, and the court allowed it in May, according to the filings Upper Seven Law posted on its case page.

03

What SB 437 says

Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, sponsored SB 437 in the 2025 session. Its enrolled text creates definitions that apply “in the Montana Code Annotated” unless the context requires otherwise. Here is what the core definitions say:

  • Sex. Whether someone is male or female, based on the type of gamete, sperm or eggs, a person is “capable of or expected to produce.” The bill says “there are only two sexes: male and female.”
  • Not identity. A person’s sex “is in no way influenced or defined by one’s psychological state, behavior, expression, or personal identity.”
  • Female and male. Each is defined by the reproductive system a person “naturally has, had, will have, or would have” but for a congenital anomaly or a disruption.
  • Gender. When used alone, “gender” must be read as a synonym for sex and may not be read as a synonym for gender identity, experienced gender, gender expression or gender role.
  • Family words. “Father” means a male parent, “mother” a female parent, and “man” and “woman” an adult human male and female.

SB 437 took effect “on passage and approval.” The bill’s findings say that “in no case is an individual’s sex determined by stipulation or self-identification.”

04

Where SB 437 reaches: licenses, records and prisons

SB 437 doesn’t stop at definitions. It amends 64 sections of Montana law to point back to them. The state forms and records it touches include:

  • Driver’s licenses. Every license application must list the applicant’s sex, “as defined in” the new section.
  • Marriage licenses. The marriage license application lists each party’s sex the same way.
  • Vital records. The definitions in Montana’s vital statistics law adopt SB 437’s meanings of “sex,” “father” and “mother.”
  • Civil rights law. The Montana Human Rights Act’s definition of “sex” points to SB 437.
  • Prisons. Two interstate corrections compacts, which govern transfers of inmates between states, define an inmate as “a male or female, as defined in” SB 437.
  • Schools and sports. The law on designating school athletic teams uses SB 437’s definitions, and so does a parental-rights law on pronouns at school.

The state pointed the court to four areas where it says the definitions are constitutional: athletics, corrections, parentage and vital records. The plaintiffs argue the law changes how they deal with the state at the motor vehicle office, when they seek marriage licenses and when they seek protection under the Human Rights Act, the Daily Montanan reported.

05

How the court applied Montana’s right to privacy

Article II, Section 10 of the Montana Constitution says the right of individual privacy “is essential to the well-being of a free society and shall not be infringed without the showing of a compelling state interest.” Halligan noted that Montana’s privacy right reaches further than the federal one and protects personal autonomy, not only secrets.

The state argued SB 437 is “entirely passive” on privacy because it demands no private information and creates no way to spread personal data. Halligan agreed the law itself sets up no data system. But she found the harm elsewhere: if the state recognizes someone only under a classification that differs from the one they live by, “That legal mismatch may require Plaintiffs to reveal private information.” That happens, she wrote, when they show a state ID, seek a service, marry or request a record.

Under the privacy clause, the state must prove a compelling interest and narrow tailoring. “Administrative convenience, clarity, and ease of implementation, standing alone, are not compelling interests,” Halligan wrote. She found the plaintiffs likely to win their privacy claim.

06

The equal protection ruling and the Kalarchik case

Montana’s equal protection clause, Article II, Section 4, also bars discrimination on account of sex or culture. Here Halligan leaned on the Montana Supreme Court. In Kalarchik v. State, decided April 14, the high court held that “Transgender discrimination is, by its very nature, sex discrimination.” It also held that being transgender is a suspect class, which calls for strict scrutiny.

The state argued the law treats everyone the same, because everyone is held to the same biological criteria. Halligan found that people whose identity matches the state’s classification keep that match in the law, and people whose identity differs lose it. At this stage, she wrote, that is a prima facie showing that SB 437 violates the equal protection clause.

The state also pointed to the bill’s provisions for intersex people. Halligan found those still place every person in “one of two statutory categories” without any individualized process.

07

What the state argues

The state’s case deserves a full hearing, and the order lays it out. The state argued that SB 437 is a separate law entitled to its own presumption of constitutionality. It said the definitions are neutral, objective and uniform, do not regulate private conduct, and serve legitimate interests in clear statutes, vital records, athletics, corrections, parentage, public health and insurance.

It also argued the plaintiffs lacked standing, that any harm was speculative, and that courts should hear individual challenges instead of blocking the whole law. Halligan agreed with one point: SB 437 “is distinct from SB 458 and is entitled to an independent presumption of constitutionality.” She still found the plaintiffs likely to prevail.

When the plaintiffs added SB 437 to the case this spring, Gianforte and House Speaker Brandon Ler said the law “codifies the long-recognized, commonsense, immutable, biologically-based definition of sex, male and female.” Their joint statement promised: “The State of Montana will defend this duly enacted law and ensure it gets a fair hearing in Montana’s judiciary.” After the ruling, a spokesperson for the governor’s office told Montana Free Press the office generally doesn’t comment on ongoing litigation.

Glimm told the Daily Montanan he was disappointed. “It’s the legislature’s job to make definitions, and unfortunately the judiciary here has stepped in and tried to take that under their own control,” he said.

08

What the injunction does not do

Halligan took pains to say what her order leaves alone. Read closely, it is narrower than a quick summary might suggest:

  • It doesn’t pick a definition. The court “does not, and should not decide, for all purposes, how Montana must define sex or gender.”
  • Biology can still matter. The court did not hold “that biological sex may never be relevant to law or policy.”
  • Sports and prisons. The order does not require schools to adopt a particular athletic policy or stop corrections officials from making individualized housing and safety decisions under existing authority.
  • Parentage and records. Courts can still determine biological parentage when it matters, and the state can still preserve original vital records.
  • The Legislature. The order “also leaves the Legislature free to enact laws that address specific, demonstrated governmental interests through means consistent with constitutional protections.”

09

How SB 437 followed SB 458

SB 437 has a history, and it starts with SB 458, which Glimm also sponsored and the 2023 Legislature passed. In June 2024, Missoula County District Judge Shane Vannatta struck SB 458 down in a separate case because its subject wasn’t clearly expressed in its title, as the Montana Constitution requires, the Daily Montanan reported.

In February 2025, in this case, Halligan went further. Her summary judgment order declared SB 458 “facially unconstitutional, in violation of the Montana Constitution’s guarantees of equal protection and privacy,” and barred the state from enforcing “SB 458, or any law with the same effect.”

Glimm’s SB 437 was introduced six days later. He acknowledged at a March 2025 Senate Judiciary hearing that “the mechanics of this bill will remain the same,” the order notes. Ler then held the bill for nearly a year before sending it to the governor, saying lawmakers wanted it to stand on its own instead of being folded into the SB 458 litigation, according to the Daily Montanan and Montana Free Press’s Capitol Tracker. Upper Seven Law’s litigation director, Molly Danahy, counted that delay among what she called “extraordinary procedural shenanigans.”

10

A timeline from SB 458 to the SB 437 injunction

These dates come from the court orders, the Legislature, Upper Seven Law’s filings and Montana reporting:

  • 2023: The Legislature passes SB 458. The plaintiffs in this case sue in Missoula County that October.
  • June 2024: Judge Vannatta strikes SB 458 down over its title.
  • December 16, 2024: In the separate Kalarchik case, a Lewis and Clark County judge blocks SB 458 and two state policies as they apply to amending birth certificates and driver’s licenses.
  • February 18, 2025: Halligan declares SB 458 facially unconstitutional.
  • March 6 and April 11, 2025: SB 437 passes the Senate 31-18 and the House 55-44.
  • April 21, 2025: The Senate president signs the bill. The House speaker holds it.
  • March 24, 2026: Gianforte signs it, the Daily Montanan reported.
  • April 6, 2026: The plaintiffs ask the court to block the new law.
  • April 14, 2026: The Montana Supreme Court upholds the Kalarchik injunction, 5-2.
  • May 22, 2026: Halligan denies a temporary restraining order and sets a hearing.
  • June 19, 2026: The court hears arguments in Missoula.
  • November 16, 2026: Halligan signs the SB 437 injunction. Upper Seven Law and Montana news outlets date it November 17.

11

What the SB 437 ruling means for your IDs and records

If you are transgender, intersex or Two Spirit and live in Montana, three court orders now stand between you and the state’s sex definitions while the cases go on. Together, they decide what you can do with your documents today.

The first is this one. While it stands, the state can’t enforce SB 437’s definitions on driver’s license or marriage license applications, in vital records, or in the Human Rights Act. The second is Halligan’s February 2025 judgment against SB 458 and “any law with the same effect.”

The third covers your documents most directly. In Kalarchik, the Montana Supreme Court upheld an order that bars the state health department and the Motor Vehicle Division from enforcing policies that keep transgender people from amending the sex on their birth certificates and driver’s licenses. The ACLU of Montana, which brought that case, says transgender Montanans “will continue to have access to accurate and usable identity documents while the case proceeds.”

“Government issued identification documents are necessary to access public life,” the high court wrote. The two injunctions are temporary, so keep copies of anything you file and anything you receive.

12

What happens next

The case now returns to the main question: whether SB 437 is unconstitutional for good. The injunction lasts until that “final adjudication.” No trial date was reported.

The state could also ask the Montana Supreme Court to review the injunction. That is what it did in Kalarchik, and it lost 5-2. The Montana Free Press and Daily Montanan reports did not say whether it will appeal this time. Halligan also said she may revisit the bond if circumstances materially change.

The Legislature returns in 2027, with SJ Howell, Montana’s first nonbinary lawmaker, leading House Democrats. Glimm told the Daily Montanan he isn’t currently planning more legislation defining sex for that session and wants to see the current litigation play out. Meanwhile, the Kalarchik case heads back to a Helena trial court, the Daily Montanan reported in April.

13

What you can do now

A court order is only as useful as the people who know it exists. Here is how to use this one:

  • Read the order yourself. The full 34-page order is public. Save a copy on your phone.
  • Get any refusal in writing. If a state office cites SB 437 to deny you a license, record or service, ask for the decision in writing. Note the date, the office and who you spoke with.
  • Know the ID case. For birth certificates and driver’s licenses, the ACLU of Montana’s Kalarchik page tracks that injunction and its filings.
  • Report discrimination on time. The Montana Human Rights Bureau investigates discrimination complaints, including sex discrimination. You have 180 days from the adverse act, or from when you discovered it, to file in writing. Call 406-444-2884 or toll-free 1-800-542-0807.
  • Talk to someone tonight. Trans Lifeline is 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project is 1-866-488-7386, and you can call or text 988.

14

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reports on how the law recognizes people, or refuses to: from Portugal weighing repeal of its Self-Determination Act to Kentucky families taking SB 150 to trial under their state constitution. Bloom publishes this report on Transgender Day of Remembrance, the day Bloom carries the names of 62 trans people lost this year. I believe every Montanan deserves to be known by their own state without surrendering their privacy to get there.

If this news brings up fear about your papers or your safety, you don’t have to sort it out alone. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups meet people where they are.

Reading a 34-page order line by line, and coming back when the case moves, takes steady work. A monthly gift keeps Bloom on stories like this one all year, and a one-time gift helps too.

15

Frequently Asked Questions

SB 437 is a 2025 Montana law, sponsored by Sen. Carl Glimm and signed by Gov. Greg Gianforte on March 24, 2026. It defines sex as binary, based on reproductive anatomy and gametes, says “gender” means sex and not gender identity, and applies those definitions across 64 sections of Montana law.

SB 437 remains on the books, but Judge Leslie Halligan’s preliminary injunction bars the state from enforcing its definitions until the case is finally decided.

She found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their claims that SB 437 violates the right to privacy and the equal protection clause of the Montana Constitution, and likely to suffer irreparable harm without an injunction.

A separate injunction, upheld by the Montana Supreme Court in April in Kalarchik v. State, bars the state from enforcing policies that keep transgender people from amending the sex on their birth certificates and driver’s licenses while that case proceeds. This week’s order adds to that protection.

SB 437 uses gamete-based wording, a reworked title and provisions for congenital anomalies. The court found its “operative effect appears to be the same” as SB 458, which the same judge declared unconstitutional in February 2025.

Neither Montana Free Press nor the Daily Montanan reported a decision. The governor’s office told Montana Free Press it generally doesn’t comment on ongoing litigation. In the Kalarchik case, the state appealed a similar injunction to the Montana Supreme Court and lost 5-2.

Trans Lifeline is 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project is 1-866-488-7386, and you can call or text 988. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more people to call.

Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ŸŒธ

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.