The E. Barrett Prettyman U.S. Courthouse in Washington, D.C., behind the Meade Memorial, the federal courthouse where the trans military ban case goes to trial

NewsroomTrans advocacyNews

Judge Orders Government to Reveal How It Built the Trans Military Ban

The service members challenging the trans military ban will see the government's internal records on how it was built. Judge Ana Reyes set a 28-day deadline and kept the January 4 trial date.

The service members challenging the trans military ban will get to see what the government said behind closed doors while it built the policy. On Monday, November 16, U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes ordered the government to hand over, within 28 days, the internal records it had withheld under the deliberative process privilege, and to answer the deposition questions its lawyers had told witnesses to refuse.

That matters because the January 4 bench trial in Washington turns on one question: whether the trans military ban rests on military readiness or on hostility toward the people it removes. The Advocate described it as a case that will decide whether the administration’s readiness concerns “explain the policy or conceal discrimination against transgender Americans.” Judge Reyes also ordered a deposition of former Army Secretary Dan Driscoll, refused to pause her order and kept the trial date. “We’re beyond allegations here,” she said, according to The Advocate.

Following this story: the transgender military ban. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.

01

What Judge Reyes ordered on November 16

The ruling came out of a 4:00 PM Eastern teleconference that the court opened to the public by phone. In a minute order in the trans military ban case, signed the same day and posted on the court docket, Judge Ana Reyes wrote that “for the reasons stated on the record,” she denied the government’s motion for a protective order and granted the discovery requests in the service members’ brief on the deliberative process privilege.

Within 28 days, the order says, the government must do three things:

  • Produce to the plaintiffs the “materials withheld under the deliberative process privilege.”
  • Provide “responses to Plaintiffs’ questions that Defense Counsel instructed witnesses not to answer on the basis of the deliberative process privilege.”
  • Stop “instructing witnesses not to answer deposition questions based on that privilege” in the depositions still to come.

The same order told both sides to schedule a two-hour deposition of Dan Driscoll. The court will consider cutting it to one hour if the government timely provides an affidavit confirming that Driscoll didn’t have conversations with the “Trump transition team,” as described to the court by email.

The ruling has limits. The Advocate reported that Judge Reyes left separate attorney-client and attorney work product claims unresolved, and made clear she wasn’t broadly reopening depositions. “Be judicious,” she said. “Don’t ask for every single one.”

She didn’t order a deposition of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and she didn’t decide whether his public statements will be admitted at trial, according to The Advocate. The plaintiffs are trans service members affected by the trans military ban. Their case is captioned Talbott v. United States in its filings and appears on the court’s docket as Talbott v. Trump.

02

What the deliberative process privilege protects

The deliberative process privilege lets the government keep parts of its internal decision-making private. In The Advocate’s words, it “generally protects internal discussions that help government officials reach decisions.” In this case, the government used it to hold back what its own motion calls “hundreds of deliberative communications and draft documents” from the time the trans military ban was being written.

The government’s motion defines the privilege through a 1975 Supreme Court case, NLRB v. Sears, Roebuck & Co. That case described documents “reflecting advisory opinions, recommendations and deliberations comprising part of a process by which governmental decisions and policies are formulated.”

The privilege, the motion says, rests on the idea that “agencies craft better rules when their employees can spell out in writing the pitfalls as well as strengths of policy options.” If officials feared every draft would become public, the argument goes, they would stop writing candidly.

But it isn’t absolute. Even the government’s filing calls it “a qualified privilege” that “can be overcome by a sufficient showing of need,” weighed case by case. On November 16, Judge Reyes ruled against the government both ways: the privilege couldn’t shield the trans military ban records at all, and even if it could, the service members’ need for it would win.

03

Why intent decides the trans military ban case

The service members’ central claim rests on equal protection, the constitutional promise that the government won’t single out a group of people for unequal treatment. Their lawyers argue that animus, meaning hostility toward a group, drove the trans military ban: both Executive Order 14183 and the Pentagon rules that carried it out, which the filings call the Hegseth Policy.

When a claim turns on why the government acted, the government’s private reasons become the evidence. The Supreme Court said as much in a 1977 case, Village of Arlington Heights, which the service members’ brief quotes: proving a discriminatory purpose “demands a sensitive inquiry into such circumstantial and direct evidence of intent as may be available.”

The brief also relied on a 1998 decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit holding that the privilege “was fashioned in cases where the governmental decisionmaking process is collateral to the plaintiff’s suit.” When intent is the whole case, the lawyers argued, letting the government withhold its deliberations “would let Defendants hide the very intent Plaintiffs must prove.”

Judge Reyes agreed. According to The Advocate, she ruled that the privilege couldn’t shield the evidence because the government’s intent is central to the service members’ constitutional claims. Even if the privilege applied, she said, their need for evidence that only the government controls outweighed its concerns, and sensitive material could receive safeguards.

She has been here before. In her March 2025 ruling temporarily blocking the trans military ban, Judge Reyes called the policy “soaked in animus and dripping with pretext.” On Monday she pointed to her earlier findings that the administration rushed the policy, lacked basic supporting data, failed to analyze contrary evidence and neglected to evaluate costs and effects on readiness. “The court has made preliminary findings on animus,” she said.

Her 2025 opinion put the point plainly, as the brief reminded her: “the Court cannot read minds,” but “it can read.” With this order, the service members will finally get more to read.

04

The 351 documents at the center of the fight

The numbers show why the deliberative process privilege mattered so much in the trans military ban case. According to the service members’ October 21 brief, the government claimed the privilege for 278 of the 351 entries on its October 1 privilege log, and for 73 more of the 126 entries on its October 14 log.

By the plaintiffs’ count, that came to 351 documents withheld or redacted under the privilege, nearly 75% of everything the government had logged. A privilege log is the list a party must give the other side describing each document it holds back and why.

The privilege also reached into depositions. The brief says government lawyers instructed witnesses not to answer questions about conversations on how the Hegseth Policy, the rules that put the trans military ban into effect, was developed and carried out. In one exchange it cites, a plaintiffs’ lawyer asked a witness, “Did you consult with anyone about EO 14183 before it was issued?” Defense counsel told the witness not to answer.

The service members argued that a judge’s private look at a small sample couldn’t stand in for the rest. “Even if none of the 20 documents reviewed in camera shows animus, the remainder may well,” the brief said.

They also pointed to history. In a 2019 case over an earlier transgender service policy, known as the Mattis Plan, the same federal court in Washington rejected the government’s attempt to use this privilege, the brief says. That case was Doe 2 v. Esper.

05

What the government argued

The Justice Department asked Judge Reyes for a protective order barring the service members from obtaining anything about the trans military ban covered by the privilege. Its October 21 motion warned that “the wholesale disregard of the Deliberative Process Privilege, rather than a granular, ad-hoc analysis, would be reversible error.”

The government argued that the trans military ban, as military policy, deserves special deference, and that opening its internal deliberations would undercut it. “Disclosure of hundreds of deliberative documents from the Department of War plainly risks chilling future policy discussions,” the motion said. It called the request “a fishing expedition.”

It also argued that intent doesn’t matter the way the service members say. Citing the Supreme Court’s 2026 decision in West Virginia v. B.P.J., the motion said “the Department’s policy should be reviewed on its own terms, without regard to any alleged subjective intent behind it.” It added that “Plaintiffs’ Equal Protection and Due Process claims do not turn on intent.”

And it pointed away from the official whose words the service members cite most. The motion said Secretary Hegseth delegated the job of writing the trans military ban policy to the Under Secretary of War for Personnel and Readiness and “was not intimately involved in deliberative communications and document drafting during the formulation process.”

The government said the service members already had plenty: over 4,000 pages of the administrative record, answers to their discovery requests and hundreds of documents produced without a privilege claim. The service members’ brief made the opposite point: the government can’t ask for deference while withholding the evidence that would show whether it’s deserved.

06

Inside Monday’s hearing

When a Justice Department attorney protested that disclosure would complicate trial preparations in the trans military ban case, Judge Reyes held firm, The Advocate reported. “I assume that the government is putting the appropriate resources that it needs to handle the case,” she said. “You’re getting the information over to the plaintiff. You’re doing it.”

The attorney, Jared Littman, argued that the ruling would prejudice the government as it prepared for trial. Judge Reyes extended her initial 21-day deadline to 28 days, but she refused to pause the order while the administration considered asking a higher court to step in. “I’m quite confident that the government can muster its resources to produce some documents,” she said.

The trans military ban trial date didn’t move either. On November 13, the government had withdrawn its plan to seek summary judgment, a ruling without trial, while insisting in its notice that “the trial is unnecessary and improper.” Judge Reyes was direct about the calendar. “We’re not moving trial date,” she said.

One exchange was about a name. When Littman repeatedly called the Pentagon the Department of War, Judge Reyes corrected him. “Every time you say Department of War, I’m going to say Department of Defense,” she said. The Advocate noted that Hegseth has restyled the department under an executive order authorizing that secondary title, but that changing its legal name requires legislation.

“While we’re in here, we’re going to call it what the statute says,” the judge said. In her courtroom, the words the law actually uses are the ones that count.

07

Why Dan Driscoll will answer questions under oath

Dan Driscoll is a former secretary of the Army. The service members want to ask him what he knows about the trans military ban, including how it was carried out, The Advocate reported. Government lawyers argued that the plaintiffs were only speculating about his role in developing it.

Judge Reyes ordered a two-hour deposition anyway. “I’m sure Mr. Driscoll can find two hours in his life to do this,” she said. A deposition is testimony taken under oath before trial, with lawyers for both sides present.

She left the government one way to shorten it. The written order says the court will consider cutting the session to one hour if the government provides an affidavit confirming that Driscoll had no conversations with the “Trump transition team.” The Advocate reported that she offered the shorter session if a sworn statement showed he had no relevant conversations with the transition team or with Hegseth, and no role in developing the executive order.

That question goes to the same issue as the withheld records. In a case about whether animus drove the trans military ban, who shaped the policy, and when, is part of the evidence.

08

How the trans military ban case got here: a timeline

These are the dates in the record Bloom reviewed:

  • March 2025: Judge Reyes temporarily blocks the trans military ban, calling it “soaked in animus and dripping with pretext.”
  • May 2025: The Supreme Court allows the administration to enforce the trans military ban while the litigation continues, The Advocate has reported.
  • March 16, 2026: Judge Reyes orders the government to produce, by April 30, the certified administrative record and the internal materials officials relied on, and sets a schedule for briefing on a possible class action, The Advocate reported.
  • June 1, 2026: The D.C. Circuit decides the government’s appeal of her injunction. The service members’ brief says the appeals court agreed they were likely to prevail on their animus claim.
  • June 30, 2026: The court sets a two-week bench trial to begin January 4, 2027, and a pretrial conference for December 7.
  • August 27, 2026: The government asks the Supreme Court to review the D.C. Circuit’s decision, in a case docketed as No. 26-272.
  • October 14, 2026: Judge Reyes requires Hegseth to answer ten written questions instead of sitting for a deposition, and orders both sides to brief the privilege.
  • October 21, 2026: The government moves for a protective order, and the service members file their brief asking for the withheld records.
  • November 2, 2026: The service members file their brief opposing Supreme Court review.
  • November 13, 2026: The government drops its plan to seek summary judgment and files motions to keep evidence out of the trans military ban trial, including Hegseth’s own words.
  • November 14, 2026: Judge Reyes replaces an in-person conference with a teleconference to resolve the discovery dispute.
  • November 16, 2026: Judge Reyes orders the records produced within 28 days and the Driscoll deposition scheduled. The government files its reply at the Supreme Court the same day.

09

What happens next in the trans military ban case

The 28-day clock. The order runs from November 16, so by Bloom’s count the records and answers are due by December 14. The government may still ask a higher court to intervene, but Judge Reyes refused to pause her order while it weighs that step.

The Driscoll deposition. The parties must schedule it, at two hours unless the government files the affidavit the order describes.

The evidence fights. Judge Reyes hasn’t decided whether Hegseth’s public statements will come in at trial. The Justice Department asked her on November 13 to keep them out, as Bloom reported on November 15, and The Advocate’s account notes she warned in October that weak written answers could still lead to his deposition.

The trial. The two-week bench trial in the trans military ban case is set to begin January 4, 2027. A bench trial means Judge Ana Reyes, not a jury, will decide the facts. The court’s October 14 order refers to eight named plaintiffs who will be called “as representatives of the class at trial,” so the outcome may reach well beyond the people who signed the lawsuit.

The Supreme Court. The government’s petition, No. 26-272, asks the justices to review the D.C. Circuit’s June 1 decision, and the government filed its reply there on November 16, according to the Supreme Court docket. That petition runs on its own track. Monday’s order governs the evidence for the January trial.

10

What service members and families can do now

If you serve, or love someone who does, here is what this ruling means for you today:

  • The trans military ban still applies. Monday’s order is about evidence, not about who may serve. The government even admits that, absent a waiver, “some service members who fall within the policy do in fact have their careers curtailed.”
  • Talk to a lawyer before you sign anything. If you face separation, get legal advice first. Bloom’s November 15 report walks through separation pay and VA benefits under the trans military ban.
  • Keep your own records. Save evaluations, awards, medical records and every notice you receive.
  • Listen in. Judge Reyes has opened recent hearings in the trans military ban case to the public by phone through the court’s public access line, under rules that bar recording or rebroadcasting. Check the docket before each hearing.
  • Don’t carry it alone. If you’re in crisis or need someone now: Trans Lifeline 877-565-8860 ยท The Trevor Project 1-866-488-7386 ยท 988 (call or text).

11

What Bloom is doing

Bloom has followed the trans military ban case from the record: the government’s November 13 request to keep Hegseth’s words out of the trial, and the way the same policy now keeps trans Australian sailors out of submarine training. Every new filing gets the same treatment: the document first, then what it means for the people it reaches. I believe the people who serve deserve to see the real reasons behind a policy that can end their careers.

If this news lands hard, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups are there when the waiting gets heavy. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

Reporting like this stays free because readers carry it. A monthly gift keeps Bloom on this case through the January trial, and a one-time gift helps too.

12

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 16, 2026, she denied the government’s motion for a protective order and gave it 28 days to produce records withheld under the deliberative process privilege, answer deposition questions witnesses were told not to answer, and stop such instructions. She also ordered a two-hour deposition of former Army Secretary Dan Driscoll.

It’s a rule that lets the government shield internal recommendations, drafts and discussions made before a decision. It’s a qualified privilege, so a court can order disclosure when the need is strong enough.

The service members’ equal protection claim says animus drove the trans military ban. Judge Reyes ruled that because intent is central to that claim, the privilege couldn’t keep the evidence of it hidden.

Within 28 days of the November 16 order, which by Bloom’s count is December 14, 2026. Judge Reyes refused to pause the deadline, according to The Advocate.

No. It’s a ruling on evidence, and the ban still applies while the case continues. Whether the policy is lawful goes to a bench trial set to begin January 4, 2027.

GLAD Law and the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, with Wardenski P.C., Zalkind Duncan & Bernstein LLP, Kropf Moseley Schmitt PLLC and O’Melveny & Myers LLP, The Advocate reported.

The government has asked the Supreme Court to review the D.C. Circuit’s June 1, 2026 decision in No. 26-272, and it filed its reply on November 16. That petition is separate from the trial court’s order on evidence.

Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ŸŒธ

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.